Fraser has been LibDem Councillor for the West End on Dundee City Council since 2001 and has topped the poll in all of the six council elections he has contested. Michael was elected to also represent the West End from May 2022 and is a hard-working addition to the West End LibDem team.
Thursday 31 July 2008
Victoria Park
Letter to the Prime Minister
Rt Hon Gordon Brown MP
10 Downing Street
LONDON SW1A 2AA
Dear Prime Minister
I wish to express my deep concern at the handling of the issue of the future of Post Offices by your Government.
The further closure programme of at least 2500 post offices throughout the UK has now impacted upon my own ward in Dundee’s West End, where after a “consultation period” of just six weeks, Post Office Limited has confirmed the closure of two local Post Offices – Lochee Road and Nethergate – which are vital community assets, particularly for the elderly and less mobile. The so-called “alternative” Post Offices are not easily accessible in terms of both topography and public transport.
I am convinced that your Government’s post office closure programme will have a huge impact on the elderly and most vulnerable members of our community as well as hitting small businesses. It is surely an indictment of your Government’s own policy that even cabinet ministers are opposing the closures in their own constituencies - while supporting them for everyone else.
Post Offices are the lifeblood of communities in both rural and urban areas, particularly when they are combined with other services, such as the local shop. When the local post office closes other services often follow suit, which can be devastating for the community.
It is vital that the true social value of this network is included as well as its economic value when looking at the long-term future of this valuable network.
In my view there is a clear need for your Government to listen to the people on the issue of Post Office closures, reverse the current closure programme, and henceforth provide the real investment needed to protect the existing network at its current size.
In addition to existing Post Office services, I believe the network should have an additional main function as the shop front or one stop shop for public bodies and a point of call for information on public services.
A wide range of services should be available in branches throughout the network.
These could include payment of vehicle excise duty, passport checking, bureau de change, Government information services via computer terminals, banking and other financial services, developing the police’s trial scheme - reception points for reporting crime, anti-social behaviour etc. Sub post offices could also act as agencies for the sale of tickets for bus and train travel, theatres, cinemas and concerts and for adult education services.
You should ensure that the Post Office network is the cornerstone of the programme to provide every UK citizen with access to a basic bank account. Post offices can play a key part in financial inclusion – they want and need the additional trade that offering basic bank accounts would provide.
I would urge you to act immediately to end the Post Office closure programme and to provide the necessary investment to ensure that the Post Office network can be preserved and enhanced with its existing number of branches.
Yours sincerely,
Cllr Fraser Macpherson
Convener of Planning & Transport
West End Ward
Dundee City Council
Wednesday 30 July 2008
Post Office Closures : Fraser comments on Wave 102 tonight
Post Office Closures : Disappointing outcome
NEWS RELEASE : Councillor slams "sham consultation" over Dundee Post Office Closures
Dundee City Council Planning & Transport Convener and West End Councillor, Fraser Macpherson, today slammed what he described as a “sham consultation” by Post Office Limited, which has resulted in the closure of four Dundee Post Offices.
Councillor Macpherson said he was in particular really concerned about the effect of the closures on elderly and people with mobility problems in his West End Ward, who will be affected by the loss of the Nethergate and Lochee Road Post Offices.
Cllr Macpherson said, “The so-called ‘consultation’ by Post Office Limited was nothing more than a sham. In the huge area of North East Scotland, Perthshire and Fife they are saving just three Post Offices – and none of the threatened ones in Dundee are to be saved. The consultation period was far too short and despite over 4000 objections to the closures across the region, it appears that Post Office Limited is more concerned with cutting vital services than listening to local people.
“Having spoken recently with the Postmaster at Nethergate Post Office, to suggest that his thriving Post Office is no longer viable flies in the face of the facts, and I am shocked at the destructiveness of Post Office Limited’s actions. To them it appears profits come before people and that is totally unacceptable.
“Ultimately, however, the finger of blame for the dire situation facing the Post Office network lies with the Westminster Labour Government, which has agreed to the closure of at least 2500 post offices throughout the UK. Labour's post office closure programme is having a huge impact on the elderly and most vulnerable members of our community as well as hitting small businesses. It is a sorry state of affairs and I am deeply disappointed to learn of the decision affecting the threatened Dundee Post Offices,” he concluded.
Tuesday 29 July 2008
Tavish Scott's campaign website ...
Lord Russell-Johnston
Monday 28 July 2008
Post Offices - a decision likely on Wednesday
As residents are well aware, there has been much local concern over Post Office Limited’s proposals to close four Dundee Post Offices. Many constituents in the West End have expressed their opposition to closing the Lochee Road and Nethergate Post Offices, both of which provide an invaluable service to local communities and, along with other city councillors, I have made clear my strong objections to the closure proposals.
The Royal Mail Scottish Press Office in Edinburgh confirmed to me today that an announcement is due on Wednesday regarding the four Dundee Post Offices and have further promised to e-mail me their announcement immediately it is made. I have reiterated the point that Post Office Limited should be listening to local communities and taking into full account the detailed evidence presented to them to make the case for keeping the Post Offices open.
The Royal Mail Scottish Press Office in Edinburgh confirmed to me today that an announcement is due on Wednesday regarding the four Dundee Post Offices and have further promised to e-mail me their announcement immediately it is made. I have reiterated the point that Post Office Limited should be listening to local communities and taking into full account the detailed evidence presented to them to make the case for keeping the Post Offices open.
I am to be speaking on GMTV on Wednesday morning to make the case for our local Post Offices and pleased to have the opportunity to do this.
On an unrelated matter, I was very concerned to learn about an incident in the lane that runs between Tait's Lane and Peddie Street which took place late on Saturday evening, and in which a local women had her handbag snatched at knife point.
You can read the full story in tonight's "Evening Telegraph" (click on the headline above to read this). As I said to the Tele, “Obviously, I’m concerned to learn about the incident and for the woman, who must have had a frightening experience. I should also say, however, that incidents of knife crime in the city are thankfully very limited.
“I urge anyone with information to contact Tayside Police on 0845 600 5705.”
Sunday 27 July 2008
The attack on welfare benefits ...
The Liberal Democrats are strongly opposed to these measures. We believe they will have a severe impact on some of the most vulnerable claimants and increase their risk of falling into poverty and even losing their homes.
This is not the first time these changes have been proposed. The Labour Government tried to reduce the backdating period for Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit in 2000 but withdrew their proposals after a Social Security Advisory Committee report strongly criticised them.
In the case of Housing Benefit, the Government’s proposals could lead to increasing levels of homelessness. Citizens Advice Bureaux, who deal with thousands of people with Housing Benefit claims every year, rightly argue that, since those who get backdated benefits have to provide substantial proof of their entitlement throughout the period of claim, it is money they genuinely need for rent and council tax arrears, and without it they are likely to fall further into poverty.
LibDem MPs have signed House of Commons Early Day Motion 1778 on Benefits Backdating and will continue to put pressure on the government to scrap these ill thought through proposals. It is yet another example of a Labour Government that has lost its way and simply now living on borrowed time.
Saturday 26 July 2008
Hillside Road/Glamis Drive junction
"The Roads Maintenance Team is aware that the carriageway surface in Hillside Road and particularly the junction, is less than ideal.
Friday 25 July 2008
Busy Friday
Dundee City Council’s Planning & Transport Convener, Cllr Fraser Macpherson, today announced that, following discussions between the City Council and Stagecoach Strathtay, two vital city bus services – the 69 serving Broughty Ferry and the 72 serving the West End – look set to be retained in a revised format.
The two bus services had been set to be withdrawn completely from 18th August, following an announcement by the operators Stagecoach Strathtay, but Cllr Macpherson said that, subject to committee approval on 11th August, the City Council had reached agreement with the bus company to retain the routes on a limited timetable.
Cllr Macpherson said that both routes provided a lifeline service for many – particularly elderly people – who live in streets that would otherwise not have a bus service. He sais that, as the ward councillor for the West End, he was very aware of the impact of the loss of the 72 service on constituents, many of whom live in sheltered housing and are very reliant upon the service, particularly as the main bus services are a steep climb uphill.
Cllr Macpherson added that he was grateful to Cllr Derek Scott from the Ferry Ward for his highlighting similar concerns about the impact of the loss of the 69 service in Broughty Ferry.
Cllr Macpherson said, “After a rather frantic week of discussions to try to get a satisfactory solution to this issue, I am pleased that we have a way forward. It will allow a minimum of three return trips each day on both the 69 and 72 services along the existing routes. Stagecoach had already indicated it would be prepared to run a reduced route service along the eastern part of the 72 route and their Operations Manager has confirmed to me that it will proceed with this in addition to the three full-route return journeys per day.
“The report to the Recess Sub-Committee will recommend that the Council assists this initially to the end of the current financial year to allow the services to be promoted during that time to encourage greater use and it also gives the City Council time to progress proposals for community transport to assist different communities across the City who do not have easy access to the main bus services.
“I am extremely grateful to all my constituents in the West End who highlighted the impact the loss of the 72 service, particularly Friends of Magdalen Green and West End Community Council. The fact that a petition of 526 people was collected in just a few days highlights the strength of feeling on this issue. I am also grateful to Cllr Derek Scott for raising similar concerns about the impact in parts of Broughty Ferry had the 69 service been completely withdrawn.
The matter will now be discussed at the City Council’s Recess Sub-Committee on 11th August where a report on the proposals will be tabled. Thereafter, subject to approval, City Council officers and Stagecoach Strathtay will discuss finalised timetables. Cllr Macpherson said that, during a recent packed meeting of West End residents to discuss the future of the 72 service, the Operations Manager of Stagecoach Strathtay had agreed to meet again with residents once matters had progressed and Cllr Macpherson confirmed that he would be arranging this meeting for immediately after the matter has been discussed and hopefully approved at Council Committee.
In conclusion, Cllr Macpherson said, “Clearly the matter still requires committee approval and the proposal sees only a limited number of buses per day, but it’s a great step forward from the position a few days ago, when it looked likely these services would be lost.”
The result was unexpected and not great for the party but the 'squeeze' was brutal and there was no more we could have done.
Normality beckons now and a few well earned weeks off before I return to my new electronic smartboard and the great kids of Bellahouston Academy.
Ian Robertson
Scottish Liberal Democrat
On Tay AM last night ...
Thursday 24 July 2008
Update : Path adjacent to Seymour Lodge
A Tayside Police representative has now written to me as follows :
“I can confirm that an order has been placed this morning with Tayside Contracts for carrying out the works to Seymour Street.
“It is anticipated that they will be on site at the start of September to carry out the works. We tried pushing for an earlier start date but due to their commitments with the school projects that is not possible.”
The pathway has deteriorated badly over the years and the commitment to resurface it and create a proper pavement edge will be a boon to local pedestrians. I am grateful to Tayside Police for its positive response on this matter.
Wednesday 23 July 2008
Post Offices - update
Residents in the areas that the Nethergate and Lochee Road Post Offices serve have contacted me asking when Post Office Limited will make a decision about the future of the Post Offices that they have said are under threat. People are naturally concerned at the possible loss of their local post office and anxious to learn the outcome of the recent consultation process by Post Office Limited.
The consultation ended on 8th July and we have yet to hear further from Post Office Limited. One constituent advised me that she has been checking the Post Office website daily to see if there is any news update on the outcome but there has been no update since 8th July.
I have therefore written to Sally Buchanan, Network Development Manager at Post Office Limited, asking that the outcome of the consultation process and Post Office Limited’s final decisions are made known as a matter of urgency. I think Post Office Limited owes it to the affected communities to make its intentions known as soon as possible.
Tuesday 22 July 2008
Sinderins Court update - lift repairs now underway
I have this morning been assured by Home Scotland’s Maintenance Officer that work to make permanent repairs to the lift were commenced by Home Scotland’s contractors Scotech at 10am yesterday and that both Home Scotland’s Maintenance Officer and their lift consultant has since paid a site visit to ensure that everything is progressing as planned.
The lift problems have caused significant problems for the sheltered tenants, breaking down some 17 times (click on headline to view earlier item about this) and although a number of temporary repairs were made, Home Scotland concluded that the complete replacement of the lift’s control panel and hydraulic unit was vital if further breakdowns were to be avoided.
Home Scotland has since advised that its normal 12 week tendering process for capital works was speeded up to enable the permanent repairs get underway. It is envisaged that the installation works will take place over two weeks and although a third week will be required for testing the new lift system, the lift should be fully operational by then.
I am very pleased that the lift at Sinderins Court is now being fully repaired – the previous lift problems were of great concern to residents who greatly rely on their being a properly functioning lift for access to and from their homes.
However, it is vital the work takes place as swiftly as possible as elderly residents cannot be without the lift for any prolonged period of time.
Monday 21 July 2008
Helicopter flights : update
Sunday 20 July 2008
Helicopter Training Flights Suspended
As residents are aware, in recent weeks I have raised numerous complaints from residents about noise caused by helicopter training flights and I am therefore pleased that a review is now taking place.
The noise complaints have come particularly from people living in the areas to the north west and north of the airport – and am aware that my colleague on Fife Council, Cllr Tim Brett, has also raised noise concerns with the airport following similar complaints from some of his constituents in the Wormit area.
I have now received confirmation from the Airport Manager that he has suspended the training flights pending a review and he has promised to update me when HIAL considers that it has come up with a solution.
Saturday 19 July 2008
Back to business ...
Above : We went to New York first - here's Janet in Times Square
Above : In New York for the 4th of July - despite drizzling rain that night, the fireworks were really spectacular.
Above : And great to see Scotland getting promoted in the centre of New York
Above : New York - Times Square - can't escape the politics!
Above : After New York, we had four days in Las Vegas - extremely hot but we had a great time!
Above : And then on to Boston - here's me there - not been to Boston before - very impressed, lovely city with loads to see.
Above : Good to see "Focus" extends to Boston!
Above : Janet in Boston
Above : We were canvassed in the street in Cambridge, MA, when visiting Harvard by a really nice lady from the Democrats and had to politely explain that, although supportive, we don't actually have a vote ... anyway, this is me there, making the preference clear!
Friday 18 July 2008
Tavish on the LibDem leadership election
Not the constitutional navel gazing of the others, but the challenges that we all face on energy costs, fuel prices and the rising cost of food.
The temptation for political parties can be to talk about the things that motivate and interest them and not the things that concern the voters.
There is of course a balance to be struck and I apologise to no one for the many occasions when I have challenged Labour politicians on issues such as the introduction of identity cards, the environment or forty-two detention without charge. But talk to many of our fellow Scots today and they will tell you that for the first time in many years they are worried about job security, wage levels and how to service the massive debt that many of them have.
This link is to my statement made on Monday 7th July on the reasons - personal and political - why I am running for Leader - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/7493638.stm
I want also, to bring energy, determination and drive to ensuring that the party pulls together and in the same direction. Our party is not just about MSPs in Holyrood. Nor MPs at Westminster. We are stronger when our elected members in Brussels, London, Edinburgh and town halls across Scotland work, engage and debate with party members. I am determined that should happen.
We have got to be at the cutting edge of debate. I am convinced that we should seize both the short term opportunities that lie ahead but also think about the long term. I took decisions on rail investment in the previous Government that will be opened by whoever is the Transport Minister in 10 years! But these decisions were right - right for the environment, transport policy and the long term.
I have served on Sir David Steel's commission on more powers for our Parliament. That needs to be radical and bold. My commitment is to encourage our party conference to bubble with new ideas - ideas form local parties and members. But this manifesto is the basis of further ideas and thinking I want to bring to Scottish politics.
I have been in touch with many party colleagues across in Scotland since I launched my campaign. I want to speak to as many members as I can in the coming weeks. I look forward to those discussions.
Let us make sure that we use this election to engage, energise and drive the party to new heights.
With best wishes
Tavish Scott
Tuesday 8 July 2008
Tavish for Scottish LibDem leader
I reproduce below the news release recently issued by Tavish confirming that he'll be a candidate :
Shetland MSP Tavish Scott has announced he is running to be the leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats. Speaking in Lerwick, he said,
“I want to lead the Scottish Liberal Democrats at a vital time in our country’s future.
Over the past twelve months Scotland’s political landscape has radically changed.
Labour is sinking under the weight of its own internal strife - and on the watch of its own Scottish captain.
The increasing cost of housing.
Scots are asking their government for help.
But their voices are being drowned out by an ever more acrimonious and pointless feud between the SNP in Edinburgh and New Labour at Westminster.
That's not good enough.
Our party must speak to Scotland’s people about those things that most concern them and not just those that most interest politicians.
So I want the Liberal Democrats to transcend the nastiness and narcissism that characterises so much of Scottish politics today.
I want to energise our party with new thinking and a fresh approach that speaks to the needs and concerns of Scotland.
Scotland needs a Parliament that helps families worried about paying their bills.
Scotland needs a Parliament that can improve our schools and hospitals at a time when there is less new money to invest.
And we must ensure that the rights and freedoms of every Scottish man and woman are protected.
We'll need big thinking to tackle these challenges.
But big thinking is what the Liberal Democrats do best.
The big achievements of the Scottish Parliament' first eight years were Liberal Democrat ideas.
But time has moved on and so must we.
So under my leadership, I want the Liberal Democrats to take the lead in setting the agenda in Scottish politics. Why I'm Standing
Our agenda must address the needs of every community in Scotland.
I was brought up here in Shetland.
I am what Shetland made me.
And I've had the good fortune to represent this community in the Scottish Parliament for nearly ten years.
This is where I've learned at first hand what community means.
This is a strong community where people know each other, trust each other, and help each other.
I entered politics because I recognised that Shetland has its own needs and circumstances.
And that our community needed a local voice to speak up for our concerns.
So I want our party to look at ways to improve life for every Scottish community.
What I do for Shetland I want to do for Scotland.
The Issues Matter
Wednesday 2 July 2008
Nicol's shock decision
Here's Nicol's message to party members :
Last week I informed the Convener of the Scottish Liberal Democrats that I intended to stand down as Party Leader.
Today I am formally announcing that decision, with immediate effect. Everyone involved in politics knows that there are stresses and strains on family life.
But when it goes beyond that, when it crosses a line, something has to be done.
And at that stage - when you have to make a choice between family and politics - there can only be one answer. The health and wellbeing of your family has got to come first.
As a party leader the responsibilities have been even more demanding. You have to be available every day, every week. There is rarely a weekend, a birthday or a family holiday when the demands of the job do not intrude.
That is not to complain – long hours and long absences from home go with the job.
But it can all have an impact.
It has been an honour and a great privilege to lead the party over the last three years and to be part of the first generation of Liberal Democrats to be in government in Britain since the Second World War.In that time the Scottish Liberal Democrats have achieved much for the people of Scotland. We succeeded in scrapping student tuition fees, in setting bold targets for renewable energy and in delivering a fair voting system for local government.
However that drive and that passion comes at a price. And it is a sacrifice that that my family should no longer have to make. Their happiness is more important than any political office and that is the reason for me standing down as leader of the Scottish Liberal Democrats.
Wednesday activities
Stagecoach Strathtay has agreed to meet with us later this month. The bus company has made clear that it is now prepared to run a more limited service but we don’t think it is acceptable and it wouldn’t cover areas like Newhall Gardens, Royal Victoria Hospital, Ninewells Hospital and Tesco Riverside, and serving these is vital for local people.
I think it must be remembered that the 72 bus service currently gives a service to many who otherwise would not have a local bus service and it is the most elderly and vulnerable who would be worst affected if the bus was withdrawn.
I am hoping that, between now and our meeting with the bus company later in July, Stagecoach Strathtay will decide to agree to keep the 72 on the road. There is no doubt that there is an extremely strong case to keep this service, which is so beneficial to our community.
Dr Liz Dick
Tuesday 1 July 2008
Tuesday Update …
We also visited the Sound Sense project - click on headline to view more - which is doing superb work to help deaf people in Dundee, Angus and Perth & Kinross.
As part of Alison's visit to Dundee, she visited Nethergate Post Office to meet the Postmaster, Mr Farhat Baig, and add her voice in support of the campaign to keep the vital Dundee Post Offices open. See photo (above right).
After her visit to Nethergate Post Office, Alison said, “I am very disappointed at the decision of Post Office Ltd to recommend closure of the four Dundee Post Offices at Lochee Road, Fairmuir, Broughty Ferry Road and Nethergate. All four provide a vital service for the communities they serve.
“It was very clear from my visit to Nethergate Post Office today that this Post Office is extremely busy and that the Postmaster has invested to improve the Post Office facilities. Mr Baig gave me detail of the continually improving sales at Nethergate Post Office and, with around 1200 customers every week, any suggestion of closing this Post Office makes no commercial sense for Post Office Ltd.
“I am strongly backing the campaign by local councillors and others in Dundee to save all four Post Offices and am writing to Post Office Ltd making clear my formal objection to the closure plans.”
I am pleased to say that the campaign to save the four Dundee Post Offices is really gathering momentum and getting support right across Dundee. In the West End, many residents have contacted me in support of the campaign.
At Nethergate Post Office, it is very clear that Mr Baig, the Postmaster, has built up an excellent business which is vital for the local community and with an increasing, not reducing, customer base, I think the case for keeping this Post Office open is very strong indeed.
We will be continuing the campaign to save the four Dundee Post Offices right up to the closing date for objections on 8th July and urge residents to make their feelings known to Post Office Ltd.